Oakland Police Chief Admits Gun Buy Back Has No Impact on Crime

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

OAKLAND Police collect more than 1,000 weapons
( But Police Chief Admits Gun Buy Backs Do Not Have Much Impact on Crime. )

Carolyn Jones, Chronicle Staff Writer February 10, 2008

Soon after Oakland streets again exploded in violence, police collected more than 1,000 handguns and assault weapons Saturday in three no-questions-asked buyback events.

State Senate President Pro Tem Don Perata, D-Oakland, who was carjacked at gunpoint Dec. 29 in North Oakland, was the first to surrender a gun. He gave police the handgun he bought 15 years ago after receiving death threats during his fight to ban assault weapons.

“There’s too many damn guns in our society, and they’re too easy to get,” he said at the buyback event at Allen Temple in East Oakland. “The fact is, if I had reached for that gun when I was being carjacked, I’d be dead right now. There’s too many people out there with nothing to lose.”

Oakland police paid $250 for every gun that was surrendered. Organizers collected more than three times the number of guns they expected and planned to give them to the Crucible, an Oakland industrial arts studio, to be melted down and sculpted into a peace monument. The buybacks came on the heels of an especially bloody stretch in Oakland, in which three people were killed and several injured in five shootings in roughly 16 hours. Violent crime is slightly higher than it was a year ago, Oakland Police Chief Wayne Tucker said Saturday.

Gun buybacks don’t seem to have much impact on crime rates, but fewer guns on the street is undeniably a good thing, Tucker said. “Guns do kill people,” he said. “So we’re happy to get as many guns out of Oakland as we can.”

For Gloria Garner, who lives down the block from Allen Temple, the gun buyback was a welcome sight. “They need to turn them all in,” she said. “I know they just turn the guns in because they want the money, but we have too many killings in Oakland, California. We need to get rid of all the guns.” Noel Deleon of San Lorenzo brought three handguns to the buyback event. He had planned to sell them on eBay, but didn’t want them to end up in the hands of criminals. “I just don’t need them anymore,” he said. “It’s a relief to get rid of them.” The Rev. J. Alfred Smith Sr. of Allen Temple said he supports gun buybacks, but would like to see more attention paid to what he calls the root causes of violence: unemployment, poor schools and depressed neighborhoods. “If we can keep one gun off the street, that’s good, but I don’t know if this solves the real problem,” he said. “So it’s both good and bad, but that’s life.”

E-mail Carolyn Jones at carolynjones@sfchronicle.com.
This article appeared on page B – 3 of the San Francisco Chronicle

This entry was posted in Crime, Gun Buy-backs. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Oakland Police Chief Admits Gun Buy Back Has No Impact on Crime

  1. L.Truett says:

    To Mr Perata; ok you have the right to turn in your gun…
    …you do not have the right to make me turn them in..
    you decided it was not prudent to go for your gun at that time..
    …what makes you think by getting rid of your gun,
    giving up the right to self protection at all times , is better..
    thats just stupid…so dont make choices for me.

    To Rev Smith; I am keeping my guns thank you…
    thats both good and bad, but hey , thats life.

  2. Kermit Keanon says:

    Iā€™m impressed, I must say. You are both educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have got hit the nail on the head. Your ideas are excellent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *